Now, 20 years after her winning season, Underwood is back, but this time as a judge.
Carrie Underwood began her rise to stardom onAmerican Idolas a small-town girl auditioning in Missouri.
As the first winner to judgeAmerican Idolofficially, it is clear thatUnderwood is qualified to judge vocals.
Custom Image by Tania Hussain
Katy Perry took on the role of being energetic and being the harshest with her critiques.
Perry did not shy away from being honest if needed.
However, Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan present as kinder and gentler in their conversations.
“Say what you feel” vs. “Constructive and honest but be kind.”
Having three singers proved to be a good idea.
Once Perry, Richie, and Bryan were the official judges,American Idolagain found mainstream success.
Even though Richie and Bryan were calm and collected, they had different experiences with music.
Unfortunately, Underwood could have an uphill battle in winning over America in this new position.
American IdolSeason 23 premieres on ABC on March 9, 2025.
